The Toronto Blue Jays compete in one of the most challenging divisions in Major League Baseball, the American League East, where fierce rivals like the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, Tampa Bay Rays, and Baltimore Orioles make every season a battle for supremacy. Each year, clinching a division title requires not only talent but also strategic depth and consistency, which the Blue Jays are striving to enhance. Despite not having secured a division title since 2015, the team is actively making significant moves this offseason aimed at boosting their chances in the upcoming 2025 season.

This offseason, the Blue Jays have made strategic additions to their roster, including the acquisition of outfielder Anthony Santander and the veteran pitcher Max Scherzer. These players bring experience and skill that can elevate the team’s performance. However, according to MLB Analyst Keegan Matheson, there remains a critical component missing from the lineup that could greatly enhance their competitive edge.

“If they were to go out, using Alonso as the best example, and add another big bat, suddenly this offense is capable of winning games too,” Matheson said via MLB Network on ‘X.’

What’s the next move for the Blue Jays following the reported signing of Max Scherzer?@KeeganMatheson talks through the team’s recent acquisitions and the potential for adding more power to the lineup. pic.twitter.com/7VO014OMz5

— MLB Network (@MLBNetwork) January 31, 2025

Matheson emphasizes the necessity of adding another powerful offensive player to the Blue Jays’ roster to transform their lineup into a formidable threat in 2025. This need for a big bat underscores the strategic planning that must occur to compete effectively within their division. With top free agents like Pete Alonso and Alex Bregman still on the market, the Blue Jays have viable options available if they choose to pursue this route.

In 2024, Alonso played all 162 games for the New York Mets, demonstrating his durability and consistent performance. He achieved a batting average of .240, hitting 34 home runs and driving in 88 RBIs, boasting an impressive .788 OPS. This kind of offensive production could immensely benefit the Blue Jays as they aim to escalate their competitive standing.

To remain competitive in the AL East against powerhouse teams such as the Yankees and Red Sox, the Blue Jays must bolster their offensive capabilities. The potential addition of a player like Alonso could significantly enhance their ability to score runs, keeping pace with their rivals. Observing whether the Blue Jays make a move for another key hitter before the 2025 season will be intriguing for fans and analysts alike.

NEXT:  Pete Alonso Talks Are ‘Advancing’ With 1 Team