Logan Ryan, the former safety for the New York Giants, has joined a growing chorus of voices advising against the idea of trading up for quarterback J.J. McCarthy in the upcoming 2024 NFL Draft. His insights reflect a significant concern among fans and analysts alike regarding team strategy and player selection.

In a recent discussion on ESPN, Ryan cautioned the Giants about the potential pitfalls of pursuing McCarthy and emphasized the importance of finding a reliable and effective No. 1 pass receiver for quarterback Daniel Jones. His comments underscore a strategic shift that the team must consider as they prepare for the draft.

“New Yorkers, if you’re listening, do not trade up to No. 4 and get J.J. McCarthy. Don’t do it,” Ryan passionately urged. He expressed skepticism, stating, “I just don’t believe that the fourth-best quarterback in this draft, whoever that may be, is better than what Daniel Jones was when he entered college.” This perspective encourages a reevaluation of the team’s current roster and future needs.

Ryan praised Jones for possessing key attributes essential for success in the NFL, including height, arm strength, and athleticism. However, he also acknowledged the significant challenge posed by Jones’s injury history, which complicates the Giants’ decision-making process moving forward.

In Ryan’s view, should the Giants eventually decide to replace Jones, it would be prudent to secure a premier pass receiver now, facilitating a smoother transition for any future quarterback. He stated, “Daniel is tall, Daniel has an arm, Daniel is athletic. We know that,” emphasizing the quarterback’s potential while also addressing the team’s urgent need for top-tier talent.

“If you’re not confident in Jones, target one of the best pass catchers available, such as (Malik) Nabers from LSU or (Rome) Odunze from Washington. Equip your future quarterback with a standout receiver. They need that support,” Ryan advised, highlighting the importance of surrounding young quarterbacks with reliable targets.

“The Giants have numerous gaps throughout their roster and desperately need a strong receiver. This draft class is rich in talented receivers — they should seize the opportunity to select one at the sixth pick.” Ryan’s insights reflect a growing consensus as the draft approaches, with even General Manager Joe Schoen indicating a willingness to overlook quarterbacks altogether in favor of other positions.