Unpacking Troy Deeney’s Controversial Stance on Mohamed Salah’s World-Class Status

The former Watford and Birmingham City striker, Troy Deeney, recently sparked considerable debate among football fans with his remarks regarding Mohamed Salah. While acknowledging Salah’s undeniable talent as ‘excellent’, Deeney controversially stated that he does not consider him to be ‘world class’. Instead, he expressed a preference for teaching his children to emulate Real Madrid’s Vinicius Jr., highlighting the subjective nature of greatness in football. This declaration has left many fans questioning Deeney’s criteria for determining a player’s world-class status.

3

During his appearance on talkSPORT Drive, Deeney was inevitably questioned about his previous comments regarding Salah’s status in light of Liverpool’s recent Champions League victory over Girona, where Salah scored the decisive penalty. Host Andy Goldstein probed Deeney on whether he harbors any reservations about Salah, to which Deeney replied affirmatively, stating, “I am a fan! I am a fan, yeah. I’m just not a big fan of everyone saying that every single player is world class.” His remarks reflect a broader discussion on the inflated use of the term ‘world class’ in today’s football.

Deeney continued to express his thoughts on the matter, noting that he had watched a Bayern Munich match where a player was labeled ‘world class’ after a single impressive performance. He emphasized that the constant elevation of players to ‘world class’ status often occurs immediately after notable performances, leading to a dilution of the term. He stated, “It’s like instantly [that happens] as soon as someone does something good,” showcasing his belief that this trend undermines the true meaning of being world class.

Furthermore, Deeney made it clear that if he had to choose the best winger in the world currently, he would still opt for Vinicius Jr.. He explained, “That’s just my personal opinion. But you know how this game is, everyone’s got an opinion.” This statement encapsulates the subjective nature of football analysis and the heated debates that arise from differing perspectives on player talents.

3

When pressed on whether he would select Salah in a dream team alongside Vinicius Jr., Deeney acknowledged that the Egyptian winger would indeed make the cut. “Yeah,” he stated. “He’d be in there. He’d be in the top four wingers at this moment in time.” This admission highlights Deeney’s recognition of Salah’s impressive performance record, which includes scoring 16 goals and providing 12 assists in just 22 games this season, underlining his value to Liverpool.

However, Deeney further elaborated on his perspective, indicating that he believes only one player can truly be categorized as world class in each position at any given time. He elaborated, “I only think it revolves around five players: a goalkeeper, a defender, a midfielder, a winger, and a striker.” This statement suggests that Deeney holds a very exclusive view on what qualifies a player as ‘world class’, emphasizing the high standards he believes should be met.

3

He concluded by stating, “I think it can revolve very quickly,” referencing the ongoing evolution of player performance standards. Deeney shared a nostalgic moment, recalling a classic match between Manchester United and Real Madrid from 2003, where Cristiano Ronaldo’s hat-trick was pivotal. He pointed out that many legendary players from that era may not have been considered world-class at the time, illustrating that perceptions of greatness can fluctuate dramatically over time.

Deeney also expressed concerns regarding the influence of social media and statistics on contemporary football discussions, explaining, “But now with social media, with stats, it’s like ‘he’s world class’, ‘he’s world class’ and ‘he’s world class’.” By highlighting these dynamics, he questioned the clarity of what defines a world-class player in today’s football climate, emphasizing the subjective nature of these judgments.

In Deeney’s view, the perception of a player as ‘world class’ can often be influenced by generational biases. He stated, “There will be 1,000 people saying Salah is great and the best player ever,” suggesting that opinions on greatness can vary widely based on individual experiences and historical contexts. He also noted that fans who witnessed Liverpool’s glory days in the 1980s might argue that John Barnes is the greatest winger in the club’s history.

Additionally, Deeney pointed out a critical weakness he perceives in Salah’s game, stating, “I think he misses a lot of big chances.” He acknowledged that this sentiment may seem contradictory, considering Salah’s impressive goal tally, but it serves to reinforce his argument that the label ‘world class’ should be reserved for those who consistently convert in high-pressure situations. This nuanced perspective on Salah’s capabilities adds depth to the ongoing debate about his status in the footballing world.